School Library Journal Mobile
Log In  |  Register          Free Newsletter Subscription
Subscribe to SLJ Magazine

Letters

By Staff -- School Library Journal, 7/1/2004

Think carefully before jumping from a public library to a school

I read the article "Trading Places" (April 2004, pp. 48–51) comparing school librarians and public librarians. I'm afraid Ms. Bromann's information was not entirely correct. In her comparison chart "Both Sides of the Fence," she states that most school librarians "work on a teacher's schedule, and there may be some additional hours. Usually no summer, evening, or weekend hours are required." This is absolutely false! Library media specialists, including myself, work many nights creating lesson plans, reading reviews, and developing reports and public relations materials for our programs. We also work on weekends. And I come in to school during the summer to check on purchase orders and any program changes that occur during that time, and I attend school board meetings when needed.

At the elementary level, library media specialists have tight schedules for teaching, planning with teachers, and working with technology. Our jobs in schools have doubled over the many years that I have been working in education. I serve on a public library board, so I do realize that public librarians are busy, too, but I am sorry Ms. Bromann misled readers on the amount of work that is required for school libraries.

Vonna J. Pitel
Imc/district media coordinator, Cedarburg School District
Cedarburg, WI

Let's Talk Salary

I read with interest your article "More Pay for Public Librarians" (April 2004, p. 13) and Jennifer Bromann's article "Trading Places ." May I add that a public librarian's paycheck is also determined by the particular library's board of trustees and the town's mayor.

I am currently the reference librarian at a New Jersey public library in an affluent community. When I was hired in January 2002, I was told that the library was a union shop and that the current contract expired at the end of that year. A new contract would be negotiated and the director was making every effort to increase staff salaries. I agreed to serve on the negotiating committee. It is now May 2004, and the library staff still does not have a new contract.

The reason in this case is political. In November 2002, the town elected a new mayor, who decided that he would handle negotiations for all unions. To save the town money, the mayor has sought to cut employee health insurance. This is a bitter pill to swallow since he did not ask the police to reduce their health insurance, only the "blue-collar" workers. The town council has now removed the mayor from negotiations and hired a labor lawyer at an approximate cost of $300 per hour. The library union is now negotiating with a state mediator.

So why do I stay? Because I work for a director who understands that life sometimes gets in the way of work. I stay because I enjoy the staff I work with and I enjoy the challenges I face every day as a public librarian. Public libraries are a labor of love. Our paychecks in many cases do not reflect the skills and knowledge that we bring to the career that we dedicate ourselves to.

Gillian Buonanno
Reference librarian, Ramsey Public Library
Ramsey, NJ


School Library Journal welcomes letters up to 300 words. They may be edited for clarity and length. Please include a daytime telephone number. Write to the Editor, School Library Journal, 360 Park Avenue South, New York, NY 10010; fax (646) 746-6689; or

e-mail slj@reedbusiness.com.

Talkback

We would love your feedback!

Post a comment

» VIEW ALL TALKBACK THREADS

Related Content

Related Content

 

By This Author

Sponsored Links




 
Advertisement

MOST POPULAR PAGES

More Content

  • Blogs
  • Podcasts
  • Photos

Blogs


Sorry, no blogs are active for this topic.

» VIEW ALL BLOGS RSS

Photos

Advertisements





SLJ NEWSLETTERS

SLJ Extra Helping
Curriculum Connections
SLJTeen
Booksmack
LJXpress
LJ Academic Newswire
LJReview Alert
LJ Criticas Review Alert
PWDaily
Children's Bookshelf
PW Comics Week
Cooking the Books
Religion BookLine
Please read our Privacy Policy
©2009 Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
All rights reserved.
Use of this Web site is subject to its Terms of Use | Privacy Policy
Please visit these other Reed Business sites