Login  |  Register          Free Newsletter Subscription
Subscribe to SLJ Magazine
NeverEndingSearch   


Link This | Email this | Blog This | Comments (8)


Wake up, for real--The laptops have hit the fan
December 3, 2008



I've been thinking about change for quite some time now.  I knew, when I helped write the proposal more than three years ago, that our state's CFF program was going to permanently change the way the way our students learn, the way our teachers teach, and the way I do business.

Heck, that ball was already rolling and rolling fast.

This week it seems like the laptops finally hit the fan.

Both the state library listserve and the CFF listserve are abuzz.  It started when one librarian expressed surprise and dismay that the school's CFF (technology integration) coach was unaware of our beloved Access PA POWER Library. Some of the librarians on the list noted that their coaches were aware of and promoted those resources.  Others reported that their coaches either were unaware of them or ignored them. 

Those posts clearly revealed a high level of librarian anxiety.  Among the big issues . . .

With laptops now in all English, science, math, and social studies classrooms:
  • Will teachers opt not to visit the library to use their own laptops?
  • Will our books and other materials go unused? 
  • Will our instructional talents be ignored and wasted?
  • Will the highly-trained technology coach usurp the tech skills teaching turf once owned by the librarian?
  • And what about information fluency?  Who will ensure those skills are delivered?
For a while, the list's argument seemed a bit farmers and ranchers.  Fortunately, a number of folks live on both listserves.  Fortunately, a number of librarian/coach teams really do talk to each other. 

The argument is itself a wake up call. 

Fact: Librarians are information and communications technology specialists.  Our Standards for the 21st-Century Learner demand this of us.

We are not allowed to pass on new strategies for gathering, evaluating, organizing, understanding, and communicating information. 

Whining about Google vs. databases and books makes us look old and small.

We are also all about RSS feeds and information portals and wikis and Nings and blogs and personal information portals and social networking. 

In fact, we should be leading in the use of new tools.  We should lead the charge advocating for their use as an intellectual freedom issue.  We should also be helping our CFF coaches and teachers integrate the tools we know and love so well, as well as the skills we commonly value.

To be fair, the CFF coaches in our state were treated to grant-funded bootcamps and online training.  The teacher-librarians were not, though we were invited to collaborative sessions prior to our own state conference.

Brenda Boyer, who is one of several coaches who is also a librarian, weighed in and gave me permission to share her response:
To all of you despairing over the encroachment of territory, or of simply feeling ignored by your teachers, I must say stop complaining and start doing something about it! Don't just sit back and watch the world pass you! It is your responsibility as a librarian to keep up with technology, educational trends, and the best research methods. It is also your responsibility to market your library AND yourself as the key to research success.  If your teachers don't know about Power Library, then seize the opportunity to teach them! Push - pull -drag... whatever it takes! Be creative.

If you teach the best research methods, your students (and teachers) will soon discover that information comes in many different formats. You must place yourself in the position of being the research expert! You probably already ARE that person in your building... and if not, well, you should be! And yes, this includes keeping up with technology.  

Yes, the CFF coaches should know that the librarian is a key to their success. But we must be ready to play that role. Please do not expect people to come to you - you must go to them!  Show them how you can make the integration of technology more effective by offering subject specific tools, databases, websites, and yes, even books!

Many of you are still in the "honeymoon" stage of your laptop programs. Being in our 5th year as a one-to-one laptop school where every student has his own computer 24/7, let me reassure you that, if properly integrated, your library usage should not go down, but up! You must change perceptions from what a library was to what is is now. We are achieving more research than before, because inquiry is now a routine part of lessons.   Remember, your library isn't just a physical room; it's also all of the online tools (like Power Library) that you can now offer all of the time. So, go and teach research skills in the Science room, or the art room, or wherever research is happening. You need to be there! Learn the software on the laptops as well as web 2.0 tools that will take projects to new heights. You must prove to your school that this fully-integrated model is possible. We all face different roadblocks; success is about learning to work around them.  Our jobs have changed; so must we!
I know a few things clearly. 

I must teach in and outside the library--through my website, my pathfinders, my wikis and my online lessons.  Sometimes I must leave the library and teach where the laptops live.  Sometimes the laptops will walk back to our library learning space for our resources, our environment, and for me.

I must partner with our coach, Ken Rodoff.  For me that's a joy. We've always worked well together.  We've always learned from each other and share.

Of course, the elephant in many of our rooms is personality.

What happens when you throw two people, who don't necessarily love each other or respect each other's skills, together in a school?  What happens when the librarian (or the library) is misperceived or perceived as a technology dinosaur?  As merely a room rather than as laboratory, production, presentation space? What happens when that perception is close to truth?  Clinging to databases as your superpower is not going to cut it.

Librarians cannot wait for the killer free seminar to hit their counties. We must train ourselves, not only in specific apps, but in embracing new strategies that engage and promote learning.  We must also smile and laugh and play a little and not be afraid to make mistakes. We must see opportunities instead of roadblocks. No more yeah buts.

Shift happened.  Our response is not optional. 

Posted by Joyce Valenza Ph.D on December 3, 2008 | Comments (8)


December 3, 2008
In response to: Wake up, for real--The laptops have hit the fan
dmcordell commented:

Joyce, This sounds a lot like what our panel discussed at NECC: the library that exists outside of time and space, the librarian who is expert, crusader, and snake oil salesman, as needed.




December 4, 2008
In response to: Wake up, for real--The laptops have hit the fan
MichaelNailor commented:

Just an interesting example -- High school students across the country in December are debating the topic that social networking sites have "on balance" a positive impact on the United States. It has been very difficult to find voices in our profession that have anything positive to say about social networking. Lots of fear of loss of control and lots of concern about privacy and predators. We really need to pay attention to Joyce's call to embrace new learning strategies -- or at least discuss them in a "fair and balanced" way.




December 4, 2008
In response to: Wake up, for real--The laptops have hit the fan
Karen Douse commented:

Amen, Sister! Library programs and librarians will continue to be relevant and necessary as long as we keep learning ourselves. Our school adopted laptops for all students in grades 7-12 in 1999 - librarians were part of the planning committee and the program's biggest cheerleaders. Since then our circulation has increased steadily - this year it is higher than any year in the past. Our students use an appropriate mix of print and online materials for their research. Our students also read for pleasure - a lot. We had to add an additional librarian to our staff - because of requests from teachers. We collaborate with teachers to plan student research projects. Yes, we still promote books - when they are the best resource. We also blog, help teachers set up wikis, and show student how to use OneNote for research organization. Most of us have Facebook pages and belong to several Ning networks. We are in an academic department that includes both library and technology. We work WITH the tech integrator as part of the school's technology team. And if we can do it, anyone can! However, a change in mindset, patience, and persistence is needed to move this type of program forward.




December 4, 2008
In response to: Wake up, for real--The laptops have hit the fan
joycevalenza commented:

What powerful comments! Thanks. So what's the disconnect? Are we, as a profession, really in two different camps?




December 5, 2008
In response to: Wake up, for real--The laptops have hit the fan
Sharon Ellner commented:

Wow! This is straight and to the point! The librarian of the 21st Century is a key person in each school IF they have the skills for information, literacy AND technology. These positions are greatly needed and will be used as long as the librarian or LMS is up-to-date on skills. Talk about job security! Learn about these new tools and then teach others! You will find much more traffic in your library once you start bringing these new tools to staff and students. Joyce, this is very well-written!




December 10, 2008
In response to: Wake up, for real--The laptops have hit the fan
Nancy White commented:

Wow! Bravo, Joyce! It does seem that we are in 2 different camps. I believe the role of the teacher-librarian has evolved - to the point where we are most valuable as an instructional coach, helping teachers to create powerful learning experiences for students using a variety of resources - while integrating opportunities for students to polish their 21st century skills - of which information literacy (or fluency) is just one category!




December 10, 2008
In response to: Wake up, for real--The laptops have hit the fan
CHAD LEHMAN commented:

"Personality" is not often discussed when it comes to collaboration between librarians and teachers. As a library media specialist myself, I seek people I get along with the best when I'm looking to try something new or am trying to find a teacher willing to "take the leap." Not enough is said about the relationships needed to make all of this week. Thanks for sharing this.




December 11, 2008
In response to: Wake up, for real--The laptops have hit the fan
Despairing commented:

What do you do if you're the sole librarian responsible for keeping the librarian open during a multi-schedule day with no separate classroom space nor any other adults to help manage the room for a school of 1500?
I think this is the ideal and I love it but many of us are still in a place where we are physically chained to the library even if our resources aren't.
I am well versed in more than enough 2.0 tools and their creative uses as well as databases - but I can't get past that I can only leave the library for about 45 minutes a day, we have faculty meetings once a month, and when I get teachers on board to do something in the library they frequently do not allow enough time to do a remotely thorough lesson or they are interested in me babysitting their classes in throwing out a lesson that they refuse to include as part of accountability for their final products.
I hate to despair and be negative, I love what I have to offer and want to share it with my school, but frequently the task feels almost Promethean in both execution and end result for the bearer of knowledge.
How do we create possibilities and become those instructional coaches when we are physically chained to our spaces - whenever I teach a class I literally take the library hostage for the rest of the school since I can't run the library and a class at the same time and computer access is a real issue for our students.
These are real concerns and I'm not sure what creative options are left for me to connect to staff and students.





POST A COMMENT
Display Name or Registered Users Login Here.
Please restrict submissions to less than 7,000 characters (including any HTML formatting).

Before submitting this form, please type the characters displayed above. Note the letters are case sensitive:


Advertisement

Advertisements





©2009 Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
All rights reserved.
Use of this Web site is subject to its Terms of Use | Privacy Policy
Please visit these other Reed Business sites