Where in the World Is Joyce Valenza?
By Brian Kenney, Editor-in-Chief -- School Library Journal,04/01/2007
For me, the March cover story in American Libraries (AL), “Mattering in the Blogosphere,” couldn’t have been timelier. SLJ had just launched a new Web site, featuring four bloggers—including me. Time to take some notes, I figured.
But as I finished reading what was an otherwise excellent article—it profiles 10 librarian bloggers—I realized something was wrong. Where was Joyce Valenza? Or Doug Johnson, Diane Chen, and Chris Harris? As a matter of fact, school librarians were conspicuously missing. Not one of those smart, funny media specialists, whose blogs I click on every day during lunchtime, appeared in the article.
As soon as the thought entered my mind, Johnson was posing the same question on LM_NET, the electronic discussion group that serves as the collective consciousness of school librarians. In an open letter to Leonard Kniffel, AL’s editor-in-chief, he wrote, “Once again ALA [American Library Association] has demonstrated that school libraries are truly the red-headed stepchild of the library world.”
Soon after, Peter Milbury, one of the founders of LM_NET, chimed in: “I have never, ever heard a legitimate reason for why we are so consistently overlooked, neglected, and omitted from American Libraries.”
I felt that both men were right. But to be certain, I went through the last two years of AL. I found only three features relating to schools: a cover story (“Why School Libraries Won’t Be Left Behind”), an article about school librarians working abroad, and another about book displays. None of AL’s many columnists are media specialists (nor are any members of its advisory committee). In most of its “big picture” stories, the school library perspective is missing.
I don’t envy Leonard Kniffel’s job at all. AL has a huge array of issues to cover and serves many different constituencies, all of whom, I bet, are screaming for more ink. And I cringe at the idea of someone performing a similar analysis of SLJ’s content (yes, we are way overdue on a feature about middle schools).
But the truth is, in AL, libraries mean public libraries, youth is code for children’s and young adult services, and students refer to college students. And that’s a problem.
In part, the argument is as simple as “no taxation without representation.” The American Association of School Librarians represents one-sixth of ALA’s membership—and many of its members support ALA by joining other divisions as well. They want their piece of the pie.
It’s also an issue because AL is our professional marketplace, where ideas are exchanged across the membership and where someone can stand on a soapbox and address the entire profession. It’s a place where those coming to the field can learn about different types of librarianship and make career choices accordingly. AL has the potential to bring us all together—except we all need to be in its pages.
School librarians are unique. They focus on the relationship between libraries and learning. They believe squarely in the educational role that libraries and librarians can play in young people’s lives—at a time when many other types of libraries are obsessed with meeting consumer needs. They represent a part of what our larger profession is all about, but which we often forget.
The reality is that by keeping school librarians out of AL, it’s really not the school folks that are losing out. It’s the rest of the library world.
Brian Kenney, Editor-in-Chiefbkenney@reedbusiness.com
Post a comment Return to article View other article discussions
| Submitted by: | Alice Yucht 4/13/2007 9:30:26 AM PT |
Brian:
"taxation without representation" -- you nailed it! The vast majority of
school librarians who belong to ALA (and AASL and ALSC and YALSA)
don't have their dues paid for by their employers, or their conference
attendance underwritten as part of their job benefits.
Yet school librarians are often the ONLY librarians that many children and
young adults ever interact with, due to geographic and time constraints.
Thank you so much for your eloquent and ongoing support!
| Submitted by: | patrick davison (psdavi01@email.com) 4/11/2007 7:45:41 AM PT |
| Location: | Hazard |
| Occupation: | Librarian |
I am an "academic" librarian. My mentors have been "school" "special" and "public" librarians--not because one type was superior to another but because they were "great" librarians and the different perspectives they could provide to the same riddle "how to be a great librarian."
| Submitted by: | Terri Jeffrey 4/10/2007 1:43:59 PM PT |
| Location: | Northwest |
| Occupation: | Middle School Library Media Specialist |
The lack of inclusion in AL seems to me to be symptomatic of all I am personally seeing in my workplace. As a newcomer to my district and to the region, I have been shaken by the lack of understanding of what a professional library program can add to the lives of students and teachers. I continue to work hard at injecting my knowledge and skills into the educational framework, but sometimes feel defeated. Thanks for asking questions and shining light on the contributions of professional media specialists.
| Submitted by: | Mark Williams (consultant@makaw.net) 4/10/2007 11:45:30 AM PT |
| Location: | southern California |
| Occupation: | retired school librarian/ school library consultant |
Excellent points, well-made. I wonder how effective ALA would be is 1/6th of its membership base ignored their renewal notices as completely as ALA ignores school librarians.
That said, I think it's wiser to work within a national organization than to metaphorically shoot ourselves in the foot by withdrawing. The weight of other behind us certainly would make national advocacy easier and more effective. The problem seems to be getting ALA to notice. Many have tried, with a notable lack of success. I don't have an answer or a method to suggest, but I CAN say that my patience with ALA is wearing a bit...
| Submitted by: | Keith Schroeder (keitschr@hssd.k12.wi.us) 4/10/2007 11:25:59 AM PT |
| Location: | Green Bay, Wisconsin |
| Occupation: | Library Media Specialist |
Too bad this isn't in AL. . . it needs to be
| Submitted by: | Peter Milbury (pmilbury@pacbell.net) 4/10/2007 9:07:23 AM PT |
| Location: | Chico, Caliofornia |
| Occupation: | Library Media Teacher |
Hi Brian,
Wonderful article. You are a gifted writer, and a great asset to our
profession. Thank you for taking a gentle, but very firm stand on our
behalf!
Peter
Post a comment Return to article View other article discussions
