K-Gr 3—This sequel to The Zebra-Striped Whale with the Polka Dot Tail (Arimax, 2001) is as dismal as its predecessor. Most of the rhymes for each letter are innocuous, while some ("Q is for quail quilting in jail") are rather peculiar and others ("L is for llama lounging in a pajama") are ungrammatical. On the book jacket, Donahue asserts that the rhymes are phonics based, but some ("I is for iguana in Tijuana") are suspect in this regard. The digital illustrations by Thalamus (the name Donahue and her husband use when they collaborate) are busy in the extreme and garishly colored. Each page has a zebra-striped border that serves to distract from, not enhance, the presentation.—Grace Oliff, Ann Blanche Smith School, Hillsdale, NJ
Be the first reader to comment.
Comment Policy:
Comment should not be empty !!!